Order your special cookie platters for any occasion!

Home
Cookie Creations
Shop
Sweet Treats
Contact Us
Allergens/Ingredients
Reviews
FAQ
Cheryl's Cookie Creations
Home
Cookie Creations
Shop
Sweet Treats
Contact Us
Allergens/Ingredients
Reviews
FAQ
More
  • Home
  • Cookie Creations
  • Shop
  • Sweet Treats
  • Contact Us
  • Allergens/Ingredients
  • Reviews
  • FAQ
  • Sign In
  • Create Account

  • Orders
  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • Orders
  • My Account
  • Sign out

Cheryl's Cookie Creations

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Cookie Creations
  • Shop
  • Sweet Treats
  • Contact Us
  • Allergens/Ingredients
  • Reviews
  • FAQ

Account


  • Orders
  • My Account
  • Sign out


  • Sign In
  • Orders
  • My Account

Follow Us on Instagram and Facebook !

Cheryl's Cookie Creations

Sugar Cookies

Classic Sugar cookie base with a modern twist!

I Do!!

5.

Wedding cake flavored butter cookie, with a white cream core, topped with white frosting, silver sugar crystals and white beads.

Simple and elegant for any wedding dessert table.

Lemon Tart

5.

We took the classic lemon cookie and combined it with a lemon curd core, decorated it all pretty like and it's one of our top sellers!

Sugar cookie with frosted animal cookies inside. This is our 3 Ring Circus

3 Ring Circus

5.

Almond Sugar Cookie base stuffed with Frosted Animal Cookies, sprinkles and topped with another frosted animal cookie. 

Party Favor

5.

Birthday cake flavored cookie with Oreo frosting core and birthday sprinkles inside! Topped with homemade cream frosting, just like a birthday  cake.... but disguised as a cookie. 

YOLO (You Obviously Love Oreos)

5.

When you love Oreos, and you love sugar cookies, you combine them because YOLO! Cookies and cream cookie.

I <3 NERDS!

AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

The gummy, sour taste of NERDS is very addicting! Paired with a bubble gum flavored cookie with sprinkles and frosting? It'll be your new favorite flavor! In  a nerdy type of way!

Lemon Raspberry

RETIRED NO LONGER AVAILABLE

Lemon flavored butter cookie loaded with crushed raspberry pop tarts, a seedless raspberry cream filled core, and finished with another pop tart, drizzled with vanilla frosting and sprinkles with sanded sugar.

Bun in the oven

EMAIL FOR DETAILS

The perfect gender reveal party favor! Inside a vanilla sugar cookie base is either a blue or a pink frosted cake pop for you to cut open a reveal the sex of your baby!

Java Chip Espress

5.

**Contains Caffeine**

Sugar cookie dough with espresso powder, espresso chocolate chips, a Java Chip Oreo core. Drizzled white chocolate and topped with a Java Chip Oreo.

Birthday Cake pizzookie

25.

2-TIERED Birthday cake flavored pizzookie. . Made to order, toppings vary according to customer specifications. (Cookie shown is a GLUTEN FREE Oreo cookie cake).


Sugar Cookie Cut Outs

Available in 4 different flavors and customizable. Please allow 3-5 days to complete custom orders. Plan accordingly.

BENGALS PRIDE

40.

SUGAR COOKIE CUT OUTS ARE COMPLETELY CUSTOMIZABLE. MINIMUM OF 1 DOZEN

DANCE COMPETITION

40.

SPORTS THEMED COOKIES FOR ANY EVENT. 1 DOZEN MINIMUM

COOKIES & MILK

CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES (REALLY!) 

Valentine’s Day

Shop all the Valentine’s Day packages. 


Chocolate Chip Cookies

Your favorite childhood cookie revamped!

Got Milk?

5.

Traditional Chocolate Chip cookie. You can't go wrong with a warm gooey middle and crispy edge chocolate chip cookie.

Cake Pop Upgrade

5.

2 year anniversary cookie... A chocolate chip cookie dough, funfetti cake pop core, birthday cake funfetti and chocolate chips, party sprinkles. Thanks for 2 fun years in business.

"You're Not You When...."

5.

Snickers inspired cookie! Caramel brown sugar cookie with a fun sized Snicker core, caramel bits, chocolate chips. Dipped in chocolate and topped with finely crushed Snickers. For those moments when you're not you when you're HANGRY!

CHIP CHIP HOORAY!

5.

Traditional Chocolate Chip cookie loaded with chocolate AND peanut butter chips. You can't go wrong with a warm gooey middle and crispy edge chocolate chip cookie with just the right amount of peanut butter chips!

S'more to Love

5.

Take that S'more and add some love to it. Our traditional Chocolate Chip Cookie with mini marshmallows, Hershey's chocolate chips and Teddy Grahams all baked inside 1 cookie!

Brookie

AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

Chocolate chip cookie and a brownie mixed together is heavenly! Dipped in chocolate and sprinkled with love. (Also available in a chocolate Brookie!)

Sweet Cinndie

AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

Cinnamon roll cookie core, brown sugar cookie, white chocolate chips rolled in cinnamon sugar, topped with Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cereal.

Marvelous & Magnificent

5.

Got Milk just got a little more marvelous and magnificent.  We added mini M&M’s and it’s a sweet tooth’s dream cookie! 

PIZZOOKIE

15.

The DEEP DISH of cookies. This cookie is cooked in an 8" skillet and is 2" deep! It is completely customizable with mix-ins and totally sharable. Get crazy, get Kooky and order yourself a PIZZOOKIE!

14" Cookie pie

20.

14" cookie filled with mini, medium and large chocolate chips. Rimmed with icing and message. Topped with course salt.

CoCo Nutty

RETIRED NO LONGER AVAILABLE

Brown sugar cookie base with chocolate chips, coconut flakes, and Keebler coconut dreams cookie core, and topped with another dream cookie and rich chocolate drizzled across.


Chocolate Cookies

Rich Chocolate cookie base.... Chocolate lover? These are for you...

Buckeye inside a chocolate cookie. The perfect Buckeye Cookie. O-H

I-O

The Buckeye

5.

Created in O-H-I-O, this chocolate cookie has the infamous Buckeye baked in the middle. 

Down & Dirty

5.

Just like your favorite childhood dessert, this dirt pudding cookie is so much fun! Chocolate cookie base with an Oreo cream core, rolled in Oreo pieces, and topped with sour gummy worms and a drizzle of frosting.

Moose Trax

5.

Chocolate cookie with mini marshmallows, peanut butter chips and chocolate chips.

Hidden Treasure

RETIRED

It's a Piñata party! You never know what you're going to get inside, it's filled with so many goodies so we had to call it Hidden Treasure! Loaded in this chocolate cookie base  are party sprinkles and stuffed with salted pretzels and a Rolo core.

Sorry Not Sorry!

RETIRED

We combined 2 classic cookies and we're Sorry NOT Sorry! 

Buckeye cookie core, surrounded by the P_NUT BUTTA LUVA cookie and baked to heights! 


Oatmeal cookies

Everything Oaty. Traditional Oatmeal cookies to build your own!

The REBEL

5.

Our family recipe from Gramma Leber (spelled backwards is REBEL) is a monster cookie that we revamped and made even better! 

Loaded with mini M&M's, chocolate chips, peanut butter and Heath Bar pieces. 

You can't go wrong with Gramma's cookie!

Caramel Apple Crisp

5.

We took the traditional Oatmeal cookie, stuffed it with caramel bits, added some apple pie filling, then topped with melted vanilla chocolate and drizzled just a bit more caramel on top!

BUILD YOUR OWN OATMEAL COOKIE

5.

We are giving YOU the ability to create your own favorite Oatmeal cookie! Choose from the mix ins available, we'll do the baking, you do the snacking! Pictured above is a personal favorite.... Dried Cranberries and Honey Roasted Pecans!


Peanut Butter and Specialty Cookies

These cookies will vary from time to time, so check back often for new flavors.

P-NUT Butta Luva

5.

Say the name like you have a mouthful of peanut butter stuck to the roof of your mouth!  This is truly a peanut butter lovers delight. Peanut Butter Cookie base with Reese's Pieces and chopped Reese's cups baked inside.

NuTs AbOuT iT!

5.

Everything peanut butter! Peanut butter cookie, creamy peanut butter core, Reece's peanut butter chips, crushed Nutter Butter cookies, topped with peanut butter drizzle, and a Nutter Butter Cookie.

Sugar Daddy

NO LONGER AVAILABLE

What happens in the kitchen doesn't always stay in the kitchen! 

This special creation is a MALT flavored cookie base with chocolate covered salted pretzel bites, caramel bites, and chocolate chips. 

The MINI offspring of this creation is 

SUGAR BABIES. 

These mini's are bite sized malt base cookies with Sugar Babies baked inside. 

Daddy makes beautiful babies!

THE HERO

5.

Our first seasonal item is our red, white and blue creation.

Named The HERO. Honoring our Veteran's and all Armed Forces personnel. 

This cookie has a full size Oreo, with red, white and blue frosting baked inside. Mixed with more white chocolate morsels, and topped with some 5 star sprinkles.

Be sure to add this to your 3 or 6 pack! Cookies will keep in the freezer for up to 6 months.

Watermelon Sugar High

5.

Watermelon flavored sugar cookie with a Oreo cream and watermelon gummy core, chocolate seed sprinkles, topped with a watermelon gummy.

I Carrot For You

5.

Carrot cake cookie? Absolutely!! Brown sugar and spice carrot cake cookie, with an Oreo Cream core, dipped in orange chocolate and green sprinkles

SAY cheese.....cake

5.

Graham cracker cookie dough base, stuffed with chocolate/vanilla swirl cheesecake bite or strawberry/vanilla cheesecake bite core. Toppings mimic the cheesecake core.

SAY cheese.....cake

5.

Graham cracker cookie dough base with a salted caramel cheesecake bite core. Topped with caramel and white chocolate.

STAY GOLD

5.

Brother cookie to our YOLO this GOLDEN OREO cookie has a cream and crushed Oreo core, mixed with a butter flavored brown sugar cookie, crushed golden Oreos and white chocolate chips. Topped with white chocolate and sprinkles. Stay golden ponyboy!


GLUTEN FREE OPTIONS

Our GF cookies are all baked first thing with separate utensils and no cross contamination of ingredients. The ingredients used are all labeled as GLUTEN FREE from the manufacturers. Most of our cookie options can be made GF. Send us a message if there is one not listed to see if we can accommodate your choice. If you are unsure of the ingredients, please make sure to contact us PRIOR to ordering to have your questions answered. (All GLUTEN FREE options come with an additional $1.50 upcharge).

The Rebel

5.

GF version of our REBEL Monster Cookie.

Gluten Free Oats are used in place of the traditional oats, and all mix-ins are labeled as GF.

Caramel Apple Crisp

5.

GLUTEN FREE Oats and flour are used in this oatmeal cookie that has apple pie filling and caramel bits inside. Topped off with drizzle white icing. 

(If you have an allergy to caramel we can substitute an organic coconut milk caramel in its place.)

YOLO (you obviously love Oreos)

5.

Although we don't use Oreo's, we couldn't pass the name up, because just like the cookie, its too good.

This is a GLUTEN FREE sugar cookie base with crushed up Kinni Toos chocolate sandwich crème cookies loaded throughout the cookie. Then drizzled with white icing.

Gluten Free 3 Ring Circus sugar cookies.

3 RING CIRCUS

RETIRED

Sugar Cookie base baked with sprinkles, GF animal Crackers and topped with another GF Animal Cookie that has been frosted with a confectioner's glaze and dipped in rainbow sprinkles.

Gluten Free Party Favor sugar cookies.

Party Favor

5.

Birthday cake flavored sugar cookie base with party sprinkles, cream filled core and topped with funfetti sprinkles.

GOT MILK?

5.

The Traditional Chocolate Chip cookie done GF style. Still soft and gooey on the inside!

S'more to Love

5.

It doesn't get any messier than this! Our gluten free cookie filled with marshmallows, chocolate chips, and topped with a Gluten Free graham cracker and a Hershey's bite!

MARVELOUS & MAGNIFICENT

5.

Just add M&M's and a traditional chocolate chip cookie becomes marvelous and magnificent! 

SALTED CARAMEL

RETIRED

That gooey chocolate chip cookie filled with caramel bits and a salted caramel square in the center.

P-NUT BUTTA LUVA

5.

Just like our original cookie, this is everything peanut butter lovers crave! A crisp bottom layer and tons of peanut butter, Reese's peanut butter cups crushed and topped with Reese's Pieces!

OK 2B BLUE

AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

This summertime classic lemon sugar cookie has a blueberry filling inside, bright yellow jimmies and is drizzled with white vanilla chocolate, and fresh blueberries when in stock.

Cookie goes away October 31st.

Gluten Free options

Most of our regular cookies can be made Gluten Free just by simply swapping out the flour, and possibly some mixins!! If you see a cookie that you'd like to have GF, drop us a message and we'd be happy to make your cookie experience enjoyable!



VEGAN OPTIONS

free milk!

5.

VEGAN chocolate chip cookie! Made with coconut milk and dark chocolate chips. You'd never know it was vegan!

The Natural

5.

Our oatmeal flavored vegan cookie is loaded with white chocolate chips and irresistibly good.


SUGAR FREE OPTIONS

Sugar free cookies are all made with SWERVE products! mix-ins are all sugar free according to manufactured packages.

Chocolate Chip

5.

For those with sugar sensitivities, this is a great cookie.

 Made in mind for those who need to watch their sugar levels, and still want a great tasting cookie.


CUSTOMIZED COOKIE PLATTERS

YOU CHOOSE YOUR COOKIES, ADD IN SOME EXTRA GOODIES, AND WE DO THE BAKING! AVAILABLE IN LARGE, MEDIUM AND SMALL PLATTERS. EMAIL FOR PRICES.

LARGE GRADUATION PLATTERS

80.

Platter shown with a pizzookie cookie, 5, 5 oz cookies, mini cookies and candies.

MINI COOKIE PLATTERS

40-50

Platter shown with 3 mini cookie flavors. 3-5 different flavors available.

FUN BUSINESS LUNCHEON COOKIE PLATTERS

Business cookie platters completely customized to your specifications. A crowd-pleasing platter of cookies for all types of cookie lovers.

HOLIDAY COOKIE PLATTERS

Holiday cookie platters completely customized to your specifications.

HOLIDAY COOKIE PLATTERS

Holiday cookie platters completely customized to your specifications.

MEDIUM HOLIDAY COOKIE PLATTERS

60.

Holiday cookie platters completely customized to your specifications.

SMALL COOKIE PLATTERS

40.

Cookie platters completely customized to your specifications.

SMALL COOKIE PLATTERS

Cookie platters completely customized to your specifications.

SMALL COOKIE PLATTERS

Cookie platters completely customized to your specifications.

SMALL COOKIE PLATTERS

Cookie platters completely customized to your specifications.


Seasonal and limited addition cookies

These cookie flavors are only available during selected time frames.

OOEY GOOEY

5.

This cookie is like eating a mini pecan pie. We make the gooey pecan filling, stuff it inside a vanilla sugar cookie, top it with more ooey gooey and drizzle some white chocolate on the top. Why wait for Thanksgiving to have this treat? 

O.M.G. (Oh My Gourd!)

5.

Another pie lover?  This pumpkin pie cookie will definitely have you saying OMG! Our classic sugar cookie base flavored with pumpkin pie truffles, spiced orange cake pop, Ghirardelli melts, pumpkin pie flavored Kit Kat’s and topped with pumpkin pie spiced icing and a pumpkin candy corn.

Lemon Tart

5.

A lemon-flavored cookie base filled with lemon curd, yellow jimmies, topped with white icing and yellow nonpareils. The perfect summertime cookie. 

Movie Night

RETIRED

Uniquely delicious! Brown sugar base with popcorn flavoring, Popcorn flavored M&M's, Sugar Babies candies, topped with a dollop of frosting, Movie theatre and kettlecorn popcorn pieces.

Snickerdoodle

5.

An all time favorite Christmas cookie, Snickerdoodle has been around for ages! This version has white and cinnamon chips mixed in and it is amazing!

Eat Me!

RETIRED

Old fashioned molasses cookies are so under rated! This cookie has cinnamon and white chips mixed in and topped with festive Christmas sprinkles.

You're Hot!

COMING BACK FALL 2022

This is a hot chocolate cookie base with a jumbo marshmallow core, mini marshmallows mixed in and topped with a mint chocolate drizzle and red sprinkles.


THEMED COOKIE PACKAGES

These cookie flavors are only available during selected time frames.

CUPID'S COOKIE

GOT MILK? CHOCOLATE CHIP HEART SHAPED COOKIE WITH A LITTLE DEBBIE BROWNIE HEART ON TOP. A MATCH MADE IN HEAVEN!

LOVE SHACK

RED VELVET COOKIE WITH A HOSTESS DING DONG CORE, WHITE CHOCOLATE CHIPS, TOPPED WITH MILK CHOCOLATE AND CREAM CHEESE FROSTING DRIZZLE.

GUILTY PLEASURE

CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH WITH A BITE-SIZED BROWNIE CORE. TOPPED WITH SALTED CARAMEL CHOCOLATE, BROWNIE PIECES, AND SPRINKLES. 

TOFFEE NUT

BROWN SUGAR COOKIE WITH A TOFFEE OREO CORE AND TOFFEE PEANUT M&M'S. TOPPED WITH MILK CHOCOLATE AND HEATH BAR PIECES.

STRAWBERRY DELIGHT

STRAWBERRY FLAVORED SUGAR COOKIE WITH CHOCOLATE SPRIKLES (FOR SEEDS). TOPPED WITH A STRAWBERRY FILLED CHOCOLATE HEART.

DONUT RESIST ME

DARK CHOCOLATE RASPBERRY COOKIE WITH DARK CHOCOLATE CHIPS AND A KRISPY KREME DONUT HOLE CORE. TOPPED WITH A RASPBERRY KIT KAT AND DRIZZLED WITH WHITE AND RASPBERRY FLAVORED FROSTING (SEEDLESS - BLACK SPRINKLES TO MIMIC THE SEEDS). 

HONEY BUN

BROWN CINNAMON SUGAR COOKIE WITH CRUSHED HONEY BUN ROLLS AND A FROSTING CORE. TOPPED WITH ADDITIONAL FROSTING AND CINNAMON CHIPS. 

SUGAR DADDY

MALT FLAVORED COOKIE BASE MIXED WITH SUGAR BABIES CANDY. TOPPED WITH A MALTED FROSTING. 

We are always looking to add more creative cookies so keep checking back!

Contact Us

Don't See what you're looking FOr? Contact us! Special orders can be taken via email!

We love our customers, and want you to be completely satisfied! We had a customer who wanted a Traditional Oatmeal Raisin cookie, and we were happy to oblige. So feel free to get in touch with us if you need something specific. We're willing to work with you to get you want you want!

Cheryl's cookie creations

cherylscookiecreations.inc@gmail.com

Hours

Open today

09:00 am – 05:00 pm

Drop us a line!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Cancel

Visit Us

Local pick up available



Contact us to get a fresh hot out of the oven cookie or other baked goods for pick-up. We will get back to you soon to confirm your order. 


Thank you for your support!

Cheryl's Cookie Creations

Liberty Township, Ohio, USA

cherylscookiecreations.inc@gmail.com

Hours

Monday - Thursday 8:00 am - 4:00 pm EST

Closed Friday - Sunday

Local Pick is Available

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Cancel

Copyright © 2023 Cheryl's Cookie Creations - All Rights Reserved.


Powered by GoDaddy Website Builder